In 2008, Marc Provencher landed a job opening Emilitsa, an upscale Greek restaurant in Portland, Maine. Although his mother is first generation Greek-American, he’d grown up nearby in Falmouth, and it was the first time he’d really been exposed to Greek food. He took to it immediately: “I just like the simplicity of Greek cuisine,” he says.
He soon began wondering why Greek food remained underappreciated. “While there’s fine dining in Italian, Spanish and French food, Greek has always been more lowbrow,” he says. “I think it’s the diner nature: They’ve dumbed down some of the cuisine—spanakopita, gyros, Greek salads. People didn’t know there was a whole other world to Greek cuisine.” Meanwhile, he’d heard about Kefi, where Michael Psilakis was serving traditional Greek taverna food alongside an all-Greek wine list, and getting raves. “I figured, if he was able to do it there, why can’t we do it a little farther north?” So when he moved to Shelburne, Vermont, he decided to try—even though there wasn’t a single Greek wine in the state. Now he has more than 50 at Taverna Khione, which he opened in April 2015, naming it after the goddess of snow.
“I just don’t see the sense in serving California wine with Greek food.” —Marc Provencher
This spring, one of his favorite dishes was braised goat: “We get whole goats in, break them down, braise the meat in white wine and lemon juice—and fennel, being that it’s in season—and serve it with trahana,” he says, referring to a Greek starch made from wheat and soured milk. “That’s it. Five ingredients. That’s the approach we take: Our hands are tied; we’re not putting any twists on it; it’s what you’d get in your grandmother’s village.”
There’s more to transmitting the “Greekness” of a dish than just the recipe, though; goat and fennel are pan-Mediterranean ingredients. “It’s eating with the hands, getting really comfortable with the food, that makes the difference,” Provencher says. “It’s the feeling: a liveliness, and a sense of comfort enough that people come in and let loose of whatever’s happening outside with their life.”
Wine is an essential part of that package, too. “Sure, there are some people who are confused; I make sure there are descriptions for each wine on the list, so they can find something that’s similar to what they are used to,” he says. And his wine suggestions sometimes raise eyebrows, like a dry, citrusy moschofilero from Spiropoulos in Mantinia for the braised goat—unusual here in the US where we’re more used to red wine with meat. But it wouldn’t be out of place in Mantinia, especially with the lemony broth. “My thought is,” he says, “let’s make it an experience.”
5573 Shelburne Rd., Shelburne, VT; 802-985-2137, tavernakhione.com
This story was featured in W&S August 2016.