Some of the best pizza in town is coming from restaurants that aren’t in the business of slinging pies or experimenting with sourdough ferments, like Mission Chinese and Gato,. And pizza is a great reason to visit Upland, a cavernous but inviting homage to chef Justin Smillie’s home state of California. His rectangular pies have a thicker, chewier crust than other New York slices, better to hold up his innovative toppings. Over a pesto and stracciatella base, he strews fresh pears, toasted pecans and arugula leaves; Calabrian sausage spices up an otherwise unadulterated tomato passata. To drink, choose from 500-some bottles.

Check out a recipe by chef Justin Smillie here.

Restaurant Info

345 Park Ave. South (at 26th St.), Manhattan, New York

New American, Pizza


2015 W&S New & Notable

This review appears in the print edtion of the April 2015 issue.
Like what you just read? Subscribe now.

Related Stories & Reviews


Upland’s Whole Crispy Mushroom

adapted from Upland chef Justin Smillie



by Zachary Sussman